Monday, October 20, 2025

Judge denies SEC’s jurisdiction over cybersecurity controls in SolarWinds case

Share

A federal judge has rejected the Securities and Exchange Commission’s attempt to oversee corporate cybersecurity controls in the aftermath of a major cyberattack. The judge’s decision in a case involving SolarWinds, a 2020 hacking victim, stated that the SEC only has authority over financial controls, not all internal controls. The judge’s ruling relieved companies concerned about potential penalties from regulators following breaches by well-resourced hackers.

The judge also dismissed SEC claims that SolarWinds attempted to cover up the severity of the breach involving Russian intelligence agents infiltrating federal agencies and tech companies. The judge allowed the SEC to pursue allegations of securities fraud against SolarWinds and a top security executive for failing to publicly disclose vulnerabilities before the hack.

The ruling has sparked debate among business leaders, security experts, and former government officials, with some expressing concerns that holding hacking victims liable for misstatements could deter them from sharing crucial information. SolarWinds expressed gratitude for industry support and is pleased with the judge’s decision to dismiss most of the SEC’s claims.

Overall, the case highlights the ongoing challenges and complexities surrounding cybersecurity in a digital age where damaging hacking incidents have become increasingly common.


Vocabulary List:

  1. Cybersecurity /ˌsaɪbərsɪˈkjʊərɪti/ (noun): The practice of protecting systems networks and programs from digital attacks.
  2. Infiltrating /ˈɪnfɪlˌtreɪtɪŋ/ (verb): Entering or gaining access to an organization or system secretly and surreptitiously.
  3. Allegations /ˌælɪˈɡeɪʃənz/ (noun): Claims or assertions made without proof typically in a legal context.
  4. Vulnerabilities /ˌvʌlnəˈrɛbɪlɪtiz/ (noun): Weaknesses in a system that can be exploited by hackers.
  5. Regulators /ˈrɛɡjʊleɪtərz/ (noun): Authorities that oversee and enforce compliance with laws and regulations.
  6. Breach /briːtʃ/ (noun): An act of breaking or failing to observe a law agreement or code of conduct.

How much do you know?

According to the judge's decision the SEC has authority over:
All internal controls
Financial controls only
Cybersecurity controls only
Regulatory controls
Which company was mentioned as a hacking victim in the case?
Microsoft
Amazon
Google
SolarWinds
The judge allowed the SEC to pursue allegations of securities fraud against SolarWinds for failing to:
Notify shareholders
Publicly disclose vulnerabilities
Enhance cybersecurity measures
Pay fines
The ruling in the case relieved companies from concerns about potential penalties related to breaches by:
Beginner hackers
Foreign governments
Well-resourced hackers
Internal employees
Some expressed concerns that holding hacking victims liable for misstatements could deter them from:
Purchasing cybersecurity insurance
Disclosing crucial information
Suing the hackers
Expanding their business
The judge's decision to dismiss most of the SEC's claims was met with:
Resentment from industry
Approval from SolarWinds
Mandated penalties
Global criticism
This question is required

Read more

Local News