Sunday, February 16, 2025

Late Submissions: Surprising Outcomes from Recent Experiments

Share

A recent investigation underscores the inherent value of adhering to deadlines, revealing that submissions rendered past their due date are frequently perceived as inferior in quality, notwithstanding their actual caliber. Furthermore, this belatedness adversely influences the perception of the individual responsible for the work.


Notably, work submitted even marginally after the stipulated deadline incurs lower assessments, while submissions received prior to the deadline do not seem to alter perceptions of quality. The timeliness of a submission appears paramount; whether one submits three weeks or merely three hours ahead of schedule, the assessment remains unchanged, as long as the deadline is duly met.


According to Sam Maglio, a social psychologist affiliated with the University of Toronto Scarborough, “Evaluators consistently employed their knowledge regarding submission timing as a pivotal factor in their assessment of artistic entries, academic submissions, or business proposals.”


The research comprised 18 distinct experiments engaging a total of 6,982 participants. Volunteers were tasked with rating an array of projects, while cognizant of their submission timings—early, on time, or late.

The same work received lower ratings when submitted post-deadline. (Fang and Maglio, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2024)

The magnitude of the detrimental impact resulting from late submissions varied across experiments, yet Maglio and his co-author, behavioral marketing scientist David Fang from the Stanford Graduate School of Business, frequently noted substantial negative repercussions.


For instance, utilizing a scale from -3 to +3, identical work attained an average score of 0.53 when categorized as submitted on time, diminishing to 0.07 when labeled as a day overdue.


Moreover, advance notification regarding impending tardiness does little to ameliorate perceptions, nor does a history of punctuality seem to mitigate negative evaluations. Consequently, both the individual and their work inevitably appear more unfavorably in the eyes of evaluators.


The effects of this phenomenon transcend age and cultural boundaries. In one scenario featuring schoolchildren in East Asia tasked with appraising each other’s artistic endeavors, late submissions were consistently ranked lower, thus indicating that even in peer interactions among younger individuals, similar biases prevail.


However, the researchers identified a salient caveat: articulating a reasonable explanation for missing a deadline can somewhat mitigate the adverse effects, although implausible excuses—such as a dog consuming the homework—are unlikely to garner sympathy.


The findings highlight the crucial role of clear communication surrounding deadlines, which significantly influences an employee’s capacity to engender a favorable impression.

As Maglio eloquently states, “It is imperative for managers to convey the rigidity of deadlines.” Furthermore, employees should proactively inform their supervisors of any extenuating circumstances contributing to a missed deadline, as this is one of the few instances in which leniency may be extended.

This research has been published in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.


Vocabulary List:

  1. Adverse /ˈæd.vɜrs/ (adjective): Preventing success or development; harmful or unfavorable.
  2. Timeliness /ˈtaɪm.lɪ.nəs/ (noun): The quality of being done at the right time.
  3. Magnitude /ˈmæɡ.nɪ.tuːd/ (noun): The great size or importance of something.
  4. Diminishing /dɪˈmɪn.ɪʃ.ɪŋ/ (verb): Making or becoming less.
  5. Biases /ˈbaɪ.əsɪz/ (noun): Inclinations or preferences that influence judgment.
  6. Circumstances /ˈsɜr.kəm.stæn.sɪz/ (noun): Facts or conditions that affect a situation.

How much do you know?


What is a key finding of the investigation regarding deadlines?
Late submissions are often perceived as inferior in quality.
Early submissions are always perceived as inferior in quality.
Submission timing has no impact on quality perception.
Late submissions are always rated better than early submissions.


According to the text, how do late submissions affect the perception of the individual responsible for the work?
Positively
Negatively
No effect
Indifferently


What did the experiments in the research involve?
Art exhibitions
Product testing
Rating projects based on submission timing
Medical trials


How did evaluators use submission timing in their assessments according to Sam Maglio?
They ignored submission timing.
They respected submission timing.
They manipulated submission timing.
They randomly selected timings.


What is one of the few instances where leniency may be extended regarding missed deadlines?
Providing implausible excuses
Being consistently late
Proactively informing supervisors of extenuating circumstances
Ignoring deadlines


How did late submissions impact the assessment scores of work?
No impact
Slight increase
Significant decrease
Overwhelming improvement


Timeliness of submissions does not affect perceptions of quality according to the text.


Providing advance notification of impending tardiness can positively influence evaluations.


Punctuality history can mitigate negative evaluations of late submissions.


Late submissions are ranked higher than early submissions among schoolchildren in East Asia.


Clear communication about deadlines is emphasized as crucial.


Implausible excuses for missing deadlines can garner sympathy.


The researchers identified a salient caveat: articulating a reasonable explanation for missing a deadline can somewhat the adverse effects.


Late submissions were consistently ranked among schoolchildren in East Asia.


According to the research, the effects of late submissions transcend age and boundaries.


Maglio stated, “It is for managers to convey the rigidity of deadlines.”


The research involved a total of 6,982 across 18 distinct experiments.


The same work received lower ratings when submitted .

This question is required


Read more

Local News